The following paper appeared in InterRidge News Vol. 8 (1), p.25-31, Spring 1999.
 
 
 

The Magofond 2 cruise: a surface and deep tow survey
on the past and present Central Indian Ridge
 
Jérôme Dyment 1, Yves Gallet 2, and the Magofond 2 scientific party:
Anne Briais 4, Rajendra Drolia 5, Sébastien Gac 1, Pascal Gente 1, Marcia Maia 1,
Serguei Mercuriev 6, Philippe Patriat 2, Gaud Pouliquen 2, Tomoyuki Sasaki 3,
Kensaku Tamaki 3, Chiori Tamura 3, and Rémy Thibaud 1
 

 1 CNRS UMR 6538 "Domaines Océaniques", Institut Universitaire Européen de la Mer, Université de Bretagne Occidentale, 1 place N. Copernic, 29280 Plouzané, France

2 CNRS UMR 7577 "Géomagnétisme, Paléomagnétisme et Géodynamique", Institut de Physique du Globe, Paris, France

3 Ocean Floor Geotectonics, Ocean Research Institute, University of Tokyo, 1-15-1 Minami-dai, Nakano-ku, Tokyo 164, Japan

4 Laboratoire d'Etudes en Océanographie et Géophysique Spatiales, Groupe de Recherches en Géodésie Spatiale - Observatoire Midi-Pyrenees, 31401 Toulouse Cedex 4, France

5 National Geophysical Research Institute, Uppal Road, Hyderabad 500007, India

6 Russian Academy of Sciences, Institute of Terrestrial Magnetism, Ionosphere and Radio Waves Propagation, Muchnoj per., Box 188, 191023, Saint Petersburg, Russia

Introduction

Tremendous efforts have been recently focussed on the study of the Indian Ocean mid-ocean ridge system. The Southeast Indian Ridge, an intermediate spreading center, displays different types of axial morphology and geophysical signature in relation to variations of the underlying mantle temperature (e.g., Cochran et al., 1997; Sempéré et al., 1997; Christie et al., 1998). The Southwest Indian Ridge offers an almost unique opportunity to study the end-member case of ultra-slow seafloor spreading (e.g. Grindlay et al., 1996; Mével et al., 1997, 1998; see also Marine Geophysical Research, special issue: the Southwest Indian Ridge, December 1997). The Rodrigues Triple Junction, where these ridges intersect, has been the subject of specific studies (e.g. Honsho et al., 1996). In contrast, the more accessible Central Indian Ridge (CIR) has been poorly studied and no systematic bathymetric and geophysical data coverage exists north of 21°S, although many reasons make it an attractive target for mid-ocean ridge studies. Among these reasons, the drastic changes in spreading rate and direction encountered by the CIR during its history and the geophysical, morphological, and geochemical evidences of ridge-hotspot interaction in a narrow corridor in the vicinity of the Rodrigues Ridge have partly motivated the Magofond 2 cruise, together with the acquisition of high resolution magnetic anomaly records through deep tow measurements in order to investigate detailed time variation of the geomagnetic field and the magnetic structure and properties of the oceanic lithosphere.

Cruise operation

The Magofond 2 cruise of R/V Marion Dufresne started in Reunion Island on October 11 th, 1998 and ended in Reunion Island on November 9 th, 1998. Operations took place in two areas in the Exclusive Economic Zone of the Republic of Mauritius (Figure 1), the first one located on the present CIR axis east of Rodrigues Island, i.e. between 18°30'S and 20°S, and the second one southeast of Mauritius Island, on oceanic crust created between 50 and 30 Ma at the CIR axis and including a major change of spreading rate and direction and a fossil ridge segment, the Mauritius Fossil Ridge (Patriat, 1987). Data acquired routinely all along the cruise include multibeam bathymetry and imagery, gravity, scalar and vector surface magnetics. Following recent improvements, the Thomson Marconi Sonar TSM 5265 multibeam echosounder of R/V Marion Dufresne provided remarkable data in terms of spatial resolution and efficiency (about 20 m for a depth of 3000 m at the optimal speed of 15 knots). Data were processed onboard using the Caraïbes software developed by IFREMER. Gravity measurements obtained by the Lacoste & Romberg marine gravimeter were tied to the reference base of Le Port at Reunion Island using a Scintrex gravimeter, courtesy of colleagues at Université de La Rochelle, France. A proton magnetometer towed 350 meters behind the ship at sea surface provided absolute measurements of the magnetic field intensity and scalar magnetic anomalies. A shipboard three-component magnetometer (STCM) from Ocean Research Institute (ORI), University of Tokyo, Japan, provided vector magnetic anomalies, useful to determine the dimensionality of the magnetized bodies and eventually the direction of the 2D bodies. It is worth noting that the surface-towed and shipboard magnetometers provide complementary information, as the STCM is unable to provide absolute measurements of the magnetic field due to the difficulty to correct adequately for the slowly time-varying viscous magnetization of the ship body. A deep tow proton magnetometer from ORI was towed about 300-900 meters above the seafloor on selected profiles navigated at slow speed (2.5 knots), for a total duration of about 8 days. A new deep tow Overhauser magnetometer recently purchased by CNRS was also tested during the cruise. Finally, two successful dredge hauls have provided about 500 kg of rock samples and sediments.

Detailed history of the Earth magnetic field

The simplistic view of a binary sequence of alternating polarity and constant intensity is no longer sustainable for the geomagnetic field evolution. The observation of consistent patterns of low-amplitude, short-wavelength anomalies, the tiny wiggles, superimposed to the well-known Vine-Matthews-Morley magnetic anomalies, has been interpreted as reflecting either short polarity reversals or geomagnetic field intensity fluctuations (e.g., Cande and Kent, 1992; Gee et al., 1996). Measurements of geomagnetic field relative paleointensity in sediment cores has also revealed consistent variations for the recent period (e.g., Roberts et al., 1997) and has raised the strongly debated question of the "saw tooth pattern" of the field intensity (e.g., Valet and Meynadier, 1993; Kok and Tauxe, 1996). A good knowledge of the field behavior, both within a given polarity period and in terms of time distribution of the polarity reversals, is essential to investigate the mechanisms of the geodynamo and the dynamics of the Earth core (e.g. Gallet and Courtillot, 1995). For mid-ocean ridge investigators, better constraints on the fine-scale evolution of the geomagnetic field means a possibility to obtain more accurate and unambiguous ages of the seafloor (see, for example, Dyment, 1998).

Surface magnetic anomalies lack the resolution required to unambiguously discriminate the origin of the tiny wiggles, i.e. short polarity reversals or intensity fluctuations, and to obtain a detailed record of the geomagnetic variations. A better resolution can only be achieved by getting measurements closer to the seafloor, using a deep tow magnetometer. A major objective of the Magofond program is to test the practicality of this approach and evaluate the potential of such deep tow magnetic studies for geomagnetic studies. For the sake of comparison with relative paleointensity records obtained from sediments, the period investigated spans the last three millions years, i.e. the profiles are collected at a mid-ocean ridge. Another advantage of such a choice is to allow the collection of conjugate profiles and therefore the identification of tectonic complexities unrelated to geomagnetic fluctuations. As for the selection of a target area, a faster spreading rate would insure a better resolution, a slower spreading rate a longer time interval surveyed for the available ship time. In addition, previous works on surface magnetic anomalies suggest that the magnetic structure of the oceanic crust is more complex at a slow / cold spreading center than at a fast / hot one (e.g., Dyment and Arkani-Hamed, 1995; Dyment et al., 1997; Dyment and Fulop, 1997). Despite a relatively slow (full) rate of 45 km/m.y., the part of the Central Indian Ridge located between 18 and 20°S is characterized by a low roughness both on the few available bathymetric profiles and on gravity anomaly maps derived from satellite altimetry (Sandwell and Smith, 1995), typical of oceanic crust formed at a hot, magmatic spreading center. Three deep tow profiles have been run across the CIR in this area up to about 3 Ma on both flanks, providing six records of the geomagnetic history for the last three millions years.

Figure 2 show surface and deep tow magnetic data collected on Deep Tow Profile 5, which cross the CIR axis at 19°10'S. The raw magnetic measurements have been reduced for the provisional IGRF model. No correction has been made for the varying altitude of the instrument, the topographic effect, the inclinations of both geomagnetic field and magnetization vectors (which result in the skewness of the anomalies), and time variations such as the diurnal solar quiet variation. Despite these effects, to be corrected in future works, and considering a high on one flank to be matched with a low on the other flank to account for the skewness of the anomalies, a good correlation is observed between both major anomalies and tiny wiggles on conjugate flanks, as suggested by lines connecting various features of the Brunhes anomaly. The best resolution for these conjugate features is 50-100 k.y. for the altitude of 300 m. The Cobb Mountain event is observed on both flanks on surface and deep tow data, the Reunion event is well marked on the northeastern flank and more subdued on the southwestern one. Spreading is clearly asymmetrical during the Brunhes and Matuyama periods on this profile, with 45% of the crust formed on the African plate and 55% on the Indian plate, but this asymmetry does not affect the good correspondence observed between conjugate magnetic features. The data collected on Deep Tow Profiles 3 and 4 are very similar to those of Figure 2. These data await further processing in order to be compared to relative paleointensity records deduced from the analysis of sediment cores.

Additional deep tow magnetic data were collected during the Magofond 2. The short Deep Tow Profile 6 surveyed anomalies 4A, 5 and 5A about 1000 meters above seafloor on the African plate. It shows tiny wiggles consistent with those described by Blakely (1974) and, more recently, by Cande et al. (1995) from data collected in the Pacific Ocean off North America, suggesting that global geomagnetic events were responsible for these tiny wiggles. The long Deep Tow Profile 1-2 cut across the Mauritius Fossil Ridge and surveyed conjugate anomalies 22 reversed to 20 reversed about 1000 meters above seafloor. No definitive evidence has been found on the unprocessed data for a short normal event within anomaly 22 reversed, as suggested by Patriat (1987) from the observation of a clear tiny wiggle within this anomaly.

Structure and magnetic properties of the oceanic crust

The classical view of rectangular prisms bearing constant magnetization has given place to more complex models, including a geometry of the extrusive basalt layer which results from spreading and lava flow piling (e.g., Kidd, 1977; Macdonald et al., 1983; Tivey, 1996); deeper magnetized layers gently sloping away from the ridge (e.g., Kidd, 1977; Cande and Kent, 1978; Arkani-Hamed, 1989; Dyment et al., 1997); magnetization intensity varying with iron content and fractionation at regional and segment scale, or with alteration at faulted areas or hydrothermal sites (e.g. Hussenoeder et al., 1996)... The collection of magnetic data at sea surface and near the seafloor helps to resolve the structure and magnetic properties of the oceanic crust.

The anomalous skewness of surface magnetic anomalies decreases with spreading rate, from a negligible value above 50 km/m.y. (half rate) to as much as 40° at about 10 km/m.y. (Dyment et al., 1994). This observation suggests that the source of the anomalies is almost exclusively made of a thick layer of iron rich, strongly magnetized extrusive basalt for fast spreading centers. Conversely, a deeper magnetic layer, possibly made of partly serpentinized lower crustal rocks, would increasingly contribute to the anomalies as the extrusive basalt gets thinner, more pervasively altered, and less magnetized with decreasing spreading rate (Dyment and Arkani-Hamed, 1995; Dyment et al., 1997). In order to test this model and investigate the relative contribution of the shallower and deeper magnetized layers at different spreading rates, a long deep tow magnetic profile has been navigated across the Mauritius Fossil Ridge between conjugate anomalies 23 (young side, 51 Ma) and anomaly 20 reversed (43 Ma), which marks the end of spreading activity. The advantage of such a fossil ridge is twofold: the proximity of conjugate anomalies makes the anomalous skewness easier to evaluate, and the progressive decrease of spreading rate allows to investigate the effect of this parameter. Magnetic measurements at sea surface, 4000 m above the seafloor, detect with four times more intensity a magnetized source located in the extrusive basalt layer than the same source in the lower crust; this ratio increase to twenty for deep tow magnetic measurements made 1000 m above the seafloor. The joint analysis of surface and deep tow data (after altitude and topography corrections, see above) for both skewness and amplitude should provide better constraints on the relative contribution of shallower and deeper magnetized layers, and therefore on the source of marine magnetic anomalies at different spreading rates. A first result, already noticeable on the unprocessed data, is a sharp decrease in the anomaly amplitude at anomaly 21r, which corresponds to spreading rates falling from 40 to 20 km/m.y. and a rapid transition between smooth and rough bathymetry (Figure 3). A similar observation has been obtained from a systematic analysis of anomaly 25 in the World's oceanic basins (Dyment and Fulop, 1997), with a clear separation of low and high anomaly amplitudes at a spreading rate of 30 km/Ma. This threshold, which roughly corresponds to the morphological transition between axial valleys and axial domes, may reflect changes in the extrusive layer thickness, in the degree of alteration, or in the iron content of the extrusive basalt.

A drastic change of spreading direction between 45 and 40 Ma

A major reorganization of the Indian Ocean mid-ocean ridge system occurred between 45 and 40 Ma (anomalies 20 to 18) as a possible consequence of the hard collision of India with Eurasia (e.g., Patriat and Achache, 1984). On the CIR, this event is marked by a rapid decrease of spreading rate followed by a 50° clockwise change of spreading direction. In an attempt to understand the detailed evolution of such a large reorganization, we have surveyed two key-area on the African plate southeast of Mauritius (Figure 4). Data on parts of the conjugate area on the Indian plate have been acquired by our Indian colleagues of the National Institute of Oceanography, Goa, India.

The first area is located southeast of the Mauritius Fracture Zone. Prior anomaly 20 reversed (43 Ma), it was part of a relatively narrow compartment, about 100 km wide, bounded by large offset transform faults. In this area, the reorganization is marked by a sharp decrease of spreading rate at anomaly 21 reversed (48 Ma; see above and Figure 3), clearly seen in the increasing roughness of the bathymetric fabric (Figure 4), and the cessation of spreading at anomaly 20 reversed (44 Ma) on a 80 km long section of the CIR, now the Mauritius Fossil Ridge, which display a large and deep axial valley filled with sediments. Deformation, breakup and finally the initiation of a new spreading center occurred along a N30°E lineament, which isolated and transferred a 300 km-long, 80 km-wide sliver of oceanic crust originally formed on the Indian plate to the African plate. The linearity and morphology of this feature as well as its direction may have led some confusion with a fracture zone; this interpretation is however not sustainable, as no conjugate feature exists on the southern flank of the Mauritius Fossil Ridge. The N120°E fabric of the older crust, clearly seen on the southeastern part of the transferred crust sliver although it is covered by sediments on most of its extent, is cut across by N170°E deformational features. The "scar" between the old and new oceanic crust is made of a through, filled by sediments, and a linear, quite continuous ridge, suggesting a strike-slip motion component in the early stage of its evolution. The new oceanic crust display a complex structure, with at least four irregular alignments of most likely volcanic mounds separated by depressions. These features trend about N50°E and seem to curve southward and tangent the "scar". Our preliminary interpretation considers the mounds as short ridge segments offset by discontinuities (the depressions) to account for the obliquity of the "scar" with respect to the new spreading direction.

Prior the spreading reorganization, the second area, located further southeast, represented a continuous section of fast spreading center, more than 300 km-long, only affected by small offset discontinuities. The decreasing spreading rates are associated to a more segmented bathymetric fabric and a rougher bathymetry, although the change appears more progressive than on the first area. Although the detailed interpretation of the magnetic anomaly is not available yet, the various trends of the bathymetric fabric clearly show that the change of direction is not synchronous. New segments, about 10 to 20° oblique to the previous direction, appears in the vicinity of the fracture zones and propagate at the expense of the older fabric or areas with complex structures, quite similarly to the model proposed by Hey et al. (1988). This process is reiterated 3 or 4 times to achieve the 50° total rotation, as clearly seen in the central part of the survey area (Figure 4). The first order segmentation is also drastically affected by the reorganization. The major fracture zone system at 22°S, 58°E, named La Boussole FZ by Patriat (1987), is actually made of two nearby fracture zones between anomalies 23 and 21 in the survey area. The southern fracture zone disappears after a 20° rotation of the nearby fabric has been achieved, and the northern one evolves to a second-order discontinuity after 40°. This observation possibly reflects the progressive decrease of the offset across this feature as a result of the ridge segment clockwise reorientation revealed by the bathymetric fabric. At the same time, the coalescence of several oblique discontinuities, which become more or less parallel to the spreading direction as this direction progressively rotates, results in the creation of a new N80°E fracture zone. Such a fracture zone may be required by the increasing offset induced by the clockwise reorientation of the segments.

The establishment of a more detailed evolution of these events and its chronology awaits further structural analyses and the integrated analysis of the new and previous surface magnetic anomaly data available in the area.

Ridge-hotspot interaction: the CIR at 19°S

As previously emphasized, the CIR presents morphological and geophysical evidences of a hotter mantle in the vicinity of Rodrigues Ridge, between Marie-Celeste and Egeria Fracture Zones (18°S-20°S). Geochemical analyses of the few available samples along the CIR also suggest a narrow corridor where the MORBs are contaminated by hotspot material showing affinities with Reunion hotspot (Mahoney et al., 1989; Humler, pers. comm.). These inferences are most likely related to the nearby Rodrigues Ridge, an off-axis bathymetric structure which extends continuously from the Mascarene Plateau to the Rodrigues Island area along a roughly N105°E direction and overlays oceanic crust created from 40 to 7 Ma. Samples dredged on the ridge have provided rather uniform ages of 7-9 Ma (Baxter, pers. comm.). Our investigation on the CIR at 19°S, triggered by a favorable setting to collect the deep tow magnetic data, gives the opportunity to study a slow spreading center (half spreading rate 2.5 km/m.y.) in a hot mantle environment and, more generally, the interaction of this ridge with the hotspot from which the Rodrigues Ridge originated.

We have collected the full bathymetric coverage of a 150 km-long section of the CIR from the ridge axis to anomaly 2A included (4 Ma) on both flanks, with extension to anomaly 3A (7 Ma) in the close vicinity of the Rodrigues Ridge (Figure 5). The ridge axis is made of a shallow axial valley, with inner floor 3000 m deep and crests 2200 m deep. The off-axis abyssal hills are quite regular and monotonous along the survey area, with hills extending continuously on as much as 130 km. The axial valley floor presents a succession of highs and lows at intervals of about 10-20 km, which have previously been interpreted as segment centers and ends (Briais and Sauter, 1998). However, the off-axis bathymetry does not show the corresponding pattern of rhombohedrons bounded by continuous traces of discontinuities as seen, for instance, between neighboring segments on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge (e.g., Gente et al., 1995), suggesting that no stable short-wavelength segmentation exists in most of the survey area. The only continuous discontinuity is observed at the northern end of the survey area and bounds a segment longer than 130 km (its southern limit is outside the survey area; if this limit is the Egeria Fracture Zone, the segment is about 180 km long). The varying trend of this discontinuity suggests that the segment has been growing between 3.5 and 0.7 Ma and may have recently started to recede. This pattern of segmentation, with long segments and minor, transient discontinuities inside, may reflect a better magma supply and hotter asthenosphere, in contrast with the smaller segments, 80 km long in average, observed on the CIR axis to the north and the south of the survey area (Parson et al., 1993).

One of the most striking discoveries of the Magofond 2 is a series of small bathymetric ridges which continues the Rodrigues Ridge eastward up to the CIR on the African flank. Immediately east of the Rodrigues Ridge, three parallel ridges trend about N80°E on oceanic crust 6.5 to 4 Ma old. These ridges, 20-40 km long and 1500 m higher than the neighboring seafloor, have been named "The Three Magi Ridges" to emphasize their linear and parallel appearance, similar to the paths of the Three Wise Men following the Star. Further east, another ridge, parallel to the previous ones and also remarkably linear, lies on oceanic crust 3.5 to 0.5 Ma old and ends on the western crest of the CIR axial valley. This ridge, 50 km long and 700 m higher than the neighboring seafloor, has been named "Gasitao Ridge" in memory of a cyclone crossed in 1988 by the first R/V Marion Dufresne a few hundreds nautical miles north of the area, which had hardly hit the ship... and durably marked the seamen and scientists onboard, among whose three participated to the Magofond 2 cruise. An alignment of volcanic edifices, parallel to the Gasitao Ridge, is observed 30 km northward, on oceanic crust of same age. Our bathymetric survey shows unambiguously that these features have no conjugate on the Indian plate, which suggests an off-axis formation although the proximity of the axis implies some relationship to be determined. Two successful dredge hauls, located on the Gasitao and Three Magi Ridges respectively, have provided relatively fresh basalt, including glass. The samples will be dated and analyzed in order to decipher the history of their emplacement (near the ridge axis or on older crust?) and the influence of the ridge and hotspot in their geochemical composition.

Conclusion

The Magofond 2 cruise has provided a collection of excellent data which, after only a preliminary analysis, lead to the following results: Acknowledgements:
We thank Captain Gauthier and the crew of R/V Marion Dufresne , B. Ollivier and the IFRTP technical team, Y. Balut, V. Courtillot, the French Embassy in Mauritius, the Government of the Republic of Mauritius, M. Beebeejaun and D.K. Lakhabhay, C. Edy from IFREMER, N. Florsch from Université de La Rochelle, R. Mukhopadhyay from NIO, India, to have contributed by different means to the success of the Magofond 2 cruise.
 

References

Figure captions